Dr. Vandana Shiva, the WTO, and GMOs in India

During our class discussion of the future of rural and agricultural development, the idea of GMOs as a future means of alleviation of poverty and hunger was advanced. Although a contentious issue, it is an empirical fact that genetically modified crops offer increased food security through drought resistant and higher-yield crop varieties. However, we should not let the promise of the technology blind us to the trade policies of some of the largest GMO producers and pushers. One of the chief problems that has arisen is the patenting of life. Large multinational corporations like Monsanto enter a country, extract the seeds and strains they consider of value, and patent them. They can then claim sole rights over the seeds and sell them back to the community they were taken from, at a premium. Given that multinational corporations have the backing of the WTO, smallholder farmers are unable to export any patented crops unless they pay a licensing fee that cuts deeper into the razor-thin profit margins of the millions of smallholder farmers in India alone. So far in India at least, the result is a surge in bankruptcy and suicide among smallholder farmers, fueled by an acutely increased sensitivity to price fluctuations and poor harvests due to the increased cost of farming for those least able to afford it.

Several developing and developed countries are actively fighting the WTO agreement that patented life (TRIPS Article 273B) and/or the rise of GMOs in general. One of the breakout stars of the resistance movement is Dr. Vandana Shiva, who succinctly and I believe convincingly argues against the WTOs IP legislation in the video embedded below. How we look at agricultural rights has important implications for discussions of globalization and human rights, which I believe makes everyone a stakeholder in the fight for agricultural sovereignty.

I have included several other resources below for learning more about the current seed-war, as well as a link to the website for Navdanya, Vandana Shiva’s organization:





2 responses to “Dr. Vandana Shiva, the WTO, and GMOs in India

  • meghanspector

    For some reason the video insists on stopping at around 3:20, put if you click right after, it will play the last few seconds of the video.

    It is also worth mentioning that while I believe she highlights many important real issues with our current methods of agribusiness, Vandana Shiva and the anti-GMO movement are very controversial, and what I’ve chosen to highlight here is heavily in her favor. If you would like to read criticism of her thinking and the movement, a google search of “Vandana Shiva controversy” will bring you a wealth of articles from the other side, and you can make your own determination of the value/validity of her complaints.

  • katy11hermann

    GMOs and seed patenting are a major issue for small scale farmers, and I believe that large farming corporations are taking advantage of vulnerable competition. It seems clear to me that the WTO needs to make a much wider effort to fairly sort the issue out. This will take legislation and policy change and the key to that is Western opinion, since the WTO is so heavily controlled by the wealthiest nations in the world.
    Something that may garner Americans attentions is how seed patenting not only is threatening farmers thousands of miles away, but also drives small scale american farmers out of business as well. As a country that prides itself on a do it yourself and individualistic attitude it is shameful that hardworking farmers who often times are inadvertently using GMOs are driven out of business by patent lawsuits. Food Inc offers a perspective on this issue and others in modern agriculture that relate to those concerns in India.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: